Skip to content
UN Comtrade Help Center

UN Comtrade Help Center

  • UN Comtrade website

Getting Started

  • Welcome to UN Comtrade
  • Read Me First (Disclaimer)
  • Use Cases
  • How to Access UN Comtrade data?
  • Subscription Plans
  • UN Comtrade Data Processing and Dissemination Pipeline
  • Policy on use and re-dissemination
  • Premium Subscribers
  • How to create an account
  • Acquiring API Subscription Keys
  • Who do we contact for support?
  • Can I book a demo of the UN Comtrade platform?

FAQ

  • Policy on use and re-dissemination
  • FAQs on Use and Re-dissemination
  • List of References & Parameter Codes
  • Exports from one country may not always align perfectly with the imports of its trading partners.
  • Bilateral asymmetries
  • Issues with UN Comtrade Website?
  • Annual totals vs sum of monthly data
  • Can I book a demo of the UN Comtrade platform?
  • Why are some converted datasets not accessible in the UI?
  • What is “SITC LTS”?
  • Why does the commodity description for some HS codes differ slightly from the official WCO version?
  • Trade valuation
  • How to Access UN Comtrade data?
  • Mode of Transport and Trade Routes
  • Does UN Comtrade provide buyer/supplier-level data?
  • How should I interpret and use quantity data in UN Comtrade?
  • What is bulk file download?
  • How do I use wildcards to query data?
  • How to use UN Comtrade via World Integrated Trade Solution (WITS)
  • What are the data sources for UN Comtrade?
  • Which new data items have been added to UN Comtrade datasets?
  • How to retrieve data for “World” exports to a country in UN Comtrade?
  • What is data preview?
  • What is data delivery?
  • Conversion factors and current/constant value
  • Supplementary Quantity Units
  • Are 6-digit commodity codes included in 4-digit commodity codes or are they separate?
  • Reported and Converted Data: Commodity Conversion Issues
  • Premium Trial Subscription
  • Who do we contact for support?
  • Showcases in Visualization Labs

Premium

  • Premium Subscribers
  • UN Comtrade Tools
  • Menu: Bulk Files

Metadata

  • Seaborne Trade Estimates – Archive
  • Country nomenclature and groupings
  • Historical Data 1900-1960 on IMTS
  • Correlation between ISIC and SITC codes (or Commodity and Industry)
  • Conversion factors and current/constant value
  • Which new data items have been added to UN Comtrade datasets?
  • What are the data sources for UN Comtrade?
  • Supplementary Quantity Units
  • Reporters and Partners
  • Taiwan, Province of China Trade Data
  • Data Conversion
  • Intermediate Goods in Trade Statistics
  • HS 2017 code 3002.19 and HS 2022 code 3822.19
  • HS 2007 code 2916.36
  • Monetary and Non-Monetary Gold in Trade Classifications (SITC, HS)
  • Areas not elsewhere specified
  • Why are China’s re-imports so high?
  • Second Partner Country
  • UN Comtrade and UNData
  • Tariffline product code description
  • Shuttle Trade
  • Trade with itself
  • Reporter country codes and their custom areas
  • Reported and Converted Data: Commodity Conversion Issues
  • Quantity unit information in detailed level data
  • Data Confidentiality in UN Comtrade
  • EU in UN Comtrade
  • Definition of luxury goods
  • Exports from one country may not always align perfectly with the imports of its trading partners.
  • Changes in trade reporting practices of countries with colonies
  • Reporting Period – Calendar Year
  • Measurement of iron trade, specifically in used cars
  • Leasing of aircraft – financial leasing
  • Hong Kong trade with China
  • Historical data on International Merchandise Trade Statistics (1900-1960)
  • Free Zones and Bunkers
  • Food provided on airlines – Transportation Services
  • Country Codes
  • China: Data availability before 1984
  • Italy: Change in Statistical Territory

Definitions

  • Trade valuation
  • Bilateral asymmetries
  • Special Trade System
  • Modes of Supply
  • Economic Territory and Statistical Territory
  • Distinction between Exports and Re-exports / Imports and Re-imports

Do more

  • UN Comtrade Tools
  • Developer tools for UN Comtrade Data

User Guide

  • How to create an account
  • Home page
  • Menu: Data
  • Menu: Data Availability
  • Menu: Bulk Files
  • Menu: Metadata
  • UN Comtrade Tools
  • UN Comtrade API
  • Showcases in Visualization Labs
  • Premium Trial Subscription
  • What is data preview?
  • What is data delivery?
  • What is tariffline data?
  • How to query data
  • How do I use wildcards to query data?
  • Downloading all data by period
  • How to use UN Comtrade via World Integrated Trade Solution (WITS)

Methodology and Manuals

  • Concepts and definitions of International Merchandise Trade Statistics
  • Concepts and definitions of Statistics of International Trade in Services
  • UN Comtrade Data Processing and Dissemination Pipeline
  • Compilation Methodology
  • Historical Data 1900-1960 on IMTS
  • IMTS Publication List
  • HS, SITC, BEC conversion and correspondence tables
  • Quantity and Weight Data in UN Comtrade

Trade in Services

  • Negative values in trade in services
  • Modes of Supply
  • EBOPS 2002: Extended Balance of Payments Services Classification
View Categories
  • Home
  • Docs
  • Definitions
  • Bilateral asymmetries

Bilateral asymmetries

2 min read

Bilateral asymmetries in trade data (both in goods and services) are a well-known phenomenon in official statistics. Bilateral trade asymmetries occur when the reported exports from country A to country B do not match the reported imports to country B from country A.

Merchandise Trade #

Three main and well-known reasons for asymmetries in bilateral merchandise trade are:

  1. the application of different criteria of partner attribution in import and export statistics
  2. the use of CIF-type values in import statistics and FOB-type values in export statistics
  3. application of different trade systems in data compilation.

International Merchandise Trade Statistics: Concepts and Definitions 2010 (IMTS 2010) was adopted by the UN Statistical Commission in 2010 and contains the following recommendations regarding partner attribution:

  1. in the case of imports, the country of origin should be recorded;
  2. in the case of exports, the country of last known destination should be recorded.

It is important to note that whereas on the imports side, compilers of trade statistics can trace the country of origin, it is sometimes impossible to trace(or predict) the country of final destination when the goods leave a country. IMTS 2010 clearly states that such partner attribution is not ideal. It explicitly warns that there are limitations to the use of data compiled on a country-of-origin basis; most notably, such an approach does not permit a symmetrical recording of the same trade transactions by the exporting country and the importing country and that this creates incomparability and detracts from the usefulness of such trade data for some types of economic analysis. The awareness of this limitation led the IMTS Expert Group to propose that country of consignment is also included in IMTS 2010 as a possible partner attribution.

There are other valid reasons why the reported exports of one country may not coincide with the reported imports of its partner country, such as:

  • Imports are reported in CIF-type values, and exports are reported in FOB-type values;
  • Time lag between exports and imports; e.g., goods leaving country A in 2012 might only reach country B in 2013;
  • Goods passing through third countries;
  • Goods entering Customs warehousing for several months;
  • Goods being classified differently;
  • Countries having different trade systems (General versus Special Trade System);
  • Goods passing through industrial processing zones may or may not be recorded by the exporting country.

For further reading on this subject, see the following links (and attachments below):

  • Reflecting Methodological Causes of Bilateral Asymmetry for the Forthcoming Revision of IMTS Concepts and Definition (2021): ISI Paper
  • UNSD Guidelines on Analyzing and Reducing Bilateral Asymmetry: Working paper (April 2019)
  • Asymmetries in official international trade statistics and analysis of globalization: Discussion paper
  • Presentation on “Asymmetries in bilateral trade statistics” (Refers to Discussion Paper above)
  • A Eurostat paper on “Asymmetry in foreign trade statistics in Mediterranean partner countries”
  • Comparing Canada’s and China’s Bilateral Trade Data in Goods and Services (Aug 2018) prepared by China-Canada Joint Working Group on Trade Statistics Reconciliation
  • Comparing Canada’s and USA bilateral trade data
  • Comparing USA’s and India’s bilateral trade data

Trade in Services #

With regards to asymmetries in trade in services, see below the relevant references:

World Bank Trade in Services Database and documentation This database includes data from 1985-2011 and tries to consolidate multiple sources of bilateral trade data in services using mirror techniques, including the OECD, Eurostat, UN, and IMF, to provide broader coverage developed and developing countries over time.

Vladimir Markhonko’s paper on Asymmetries in official international trade statistics and analysis of globalization — section D on trade in services

IMF Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics, 2004 International Trade in Services Statistics—Monitoring Progress on Implementation of the Manual and Assessing Data Quality

IMF Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics, 2007 Preliminary Investigations into Asymmetries in Bilateral Trade in Services Between the USA and the UK

Share This Article :
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
Trade valuationSpecial Trade System
Table of Contents
  • Merchandise Trade
  • Trade in Services
© 2025 UN Comtrade Help Center • Built with GeneratePress